Why Are My Roof Quotes So Different?

Nine legitimate reasons two roofers price the same house differently, and the three that should worry you.

Call 07476 888638 for a free, no-obligation quote. Available Mon–Sun, 9am–6pm.

Three quotes, three numbers, hundreds or thousands of pounds apart. It is the most common reason people ring us for a fourth opinion, and the differences almost always come down to a small number of decisions that the quotes do not spell out.

This guide is not about cost bands. It is about learning to read what a price is actually buying.

Nine things that legitimately move the price

None of these are padding. Each one is real work or real material that either is or is not in the price you have been given.

  • Pitch, because steep roofs are slower and need more protection
  • Shape, because hips, valleys and dormers are cut by hand
  • Covering choice, from concrete tile through to natural slate
  • Underlay, breathable membrane against reused or cheap felt
  • Battens, new treated timber at the right gauge against reusing old
  • Ridge and verge method, dry fixed systems against mortar bedding
  • Lead work, correct code lead against mortar fillets or tape
  • Access, scaffold design, duration and any awkward elevations
  • Waste, skips or grab hire and the tonnage coming off

The hidden variable: what is under the tiles

Nobody knows the condition of the battens and rafter feet until the covering comes off. An optimistic quote assumes everything is sound. A realistic one states what happens if it is not, and at what rate.

Ask every roofer that one question in writing. The answer tells you more about how the job will go than any part of the headline figure.

Three differences that should worry you

A price notably below the others with no scaffold line. A quote that does not name the covering or the membrane. And a deposit request larger than the material order could possibly justify.

Cheap is not the same as bad, but unexplained is a risk you are carrying, not the roofer.

How we quote

We inspect the roof and the loft, measure, photograph anything relevant, then write the quote so you can see the covering, the membrane, the batten treatment, the ridge and verge method, the lead work and the access. If we think a repair would serve you better than a replacement, we will say so, because roof repair is the bulk of what we do.

Want a professional to handle it?

Get Your Free, Personalised Quote

Tell us about your roofing job and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

No spam, no obligation. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Free Inspections
Fast Response
Reliable Workmanship
West Glamorgan Coverage

Questions

Is the middle quote usually the right one?

Not reliably. Compare the specification line by line first. Sometimes the highest quote is the only one pricing the whole job.

Should a quote be itemised?

Yes. You should be able to see materials, access and labour treated separately enough to compare against another roofer.

Can a quote change once work starts?

Only for something that could not be seen beforehand, such as rotten rafter feet. It should be shown to you, agreed and priced before it is carried out.

Does the time of year affect price?

Availability more than price. Autumn and winter are the busiest months for roof work in Wales, so lead times stretch.

Will you review quotes I already have?

Yes. Bring them to the free inspection and we will go through what each one includes and leaves out.

Related services