Should I Re Roof in Tiles or Slate?

A practical comparison for Welsh housing, including the structural question most people are never asked.

Call 07476 888638 for a free, no-obligation quote. Available Mon–Sun, 9am–6pm.

In this part of Wales the choice is loaded with history. Slate came out of the ground not far from here and sits on a huge proportion of the older housing stock, while concrete tile went onto most of what was built after the war.

Both are good roofs. Choosing between them comes down to the structure you already have, the pitch, the look you want and how long you want to buy.

Direct comparison

Figures are supply and fit, excluding access and disposal.

The structural question

Weight is the part that catches people out. Going from natural slate to concrete tile can more than double the load on the rafters, and roofs built for slate were not designed for it. That is why plenty of houses re roofed in the 1970s now have sagging or spread structures.

Going the other way, slate onto a structure built for tile, is structurally easy and often the right restoration choice, but the battens and fixings all change.

How each behaves in Welsh weather

Slate sheds wind driven rain very well and its fixings are the weak point rather than the material, which is why old slate roofs fail one slate at a time rather than all at once.

Concrete tile is robust and cheap to replace, but its surface erodes over decades and it becomes porous, which shows as moss holding on and colour going patchy. Clay sits between the two: it keeps its colour for the whole of its life and it is the tile we would choose for a house where appearance matters.

Which we would suggest

For a Victorian or Edwardian terrace, slate or a good fibre cement slate, because anything else looks imposed. For a post war semi already carrying tile, tile again, in clay if the budget allows. For a bungalow or an extension where cost leads, concrete interlocking tile is honest value.

We will always tell you what the structure can carry before we discuss what you would prefer.

Want a professional to handle it?

Get Your Free, Personalised Quote

Tell us about your roofing job and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

No spam, no obligation. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Free Inspections
Fast Response
Reliable Workmanship
West Glamorgan Coverage

Questions

Is fibre cement slate a fair substitute?

For appearance and budget, yes, and it is light. It will not last as long as natural slate, so it is a thirty to fifty year decision rather than a lifetime one.

Can I swap tile for slate on the same rafters?

Structurally that direction is usually fine because slate is lighter. Battens, gauge and fixings all change, so it is a full re roof rather than a swap.

Does a conservation area restrict the choice?

It can, particularly on visible elevations of older property. Check with the local authority before ordering material.

Which is cheaper to repair later?

Tile, because a replacement unit slots in. Slate repairs are more skilled but a well fixed slate roof needs them far less often.

Will you tell me if the roof cannot take tile?

Yes, at the inspection, from the rafter sizes, the spans and the condition of the existing structure.

Related services