Which Flat Roof System Should I Choose?

A working roofer's comparison of the three systems used on almost every domestic flat roof in Wales.

Call 07476 888638 for a free, no-obligation quote. Available Mon–Sun, 9am–6pm.

Fibreglass, felt and rubber all keep water out when they are laid well, and all three leak when they are not. What separates them in practice is how they behave at the awkward parts of a roof: the upstands, the outlets, the trims and the junctions with a wall.

This guide compares them on the things that actually decide how long your roof lasts.

Side by side

Figures are for well installed domestic work on a sound deck.

Torch on felt

Modern two and three layer torch on felt is nothing like the single layer felt that gave flat roofs their reputation. It is tough, easy to detail around awkward shapes and simple to repair years later.

Its weakness is heat during installation and the number of laps on a big roof, each one a place where workmanship shows.

GRP fibreglass

Laid wet and cured in place, so a small roof ends up seamless and rigid. It takes trims and rooflight kerbs beautifully, which makes it a good match for roofs with a lantern or several penetrations.

It needs a dry, warm enough day and a well prepared deck, and it does not like movement, so the deck below has to be right.

EPDM rubber

A single rubber membrane, often one piece on a domestic roof, bonded to the deck. Very few joints means very few places to fail, and it stays flexible in cold weather.

Corners and upstands are the skill, and the deck needs to be clean and smooth because the membrane will telegraph anything left under it.

Want a professional to handle it?

Get Your Free, Personalised Quote

Tell us about your roofing job and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

No spam, no obligation. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Free Inspections
Fast Response
Reliable Workmanship
West Glamorgan Coverage

Questions

Which system do you fit most often?

It depends on the roof rather than a house preference. Simple rectangles suit rubber, roofs with lanterns and kerbs often suit fibreglass, and larger or more complicated roofs often suit felt.

Can I put one system over another?

Not reliably. Resins and adhesives are fussy about what they bond to, and mixing systems is a common cause of early failure.

Does the guarantee come from the maker or the roofer?

Both matter. Material warranties cover the product, and a workmanship guarantee covers the installation. Ask for both in writing.

Will a rooflight work with all three?

Yes, with the right kerb detail. What matters is that the upstand is high enough and the covering is dressed up it properly.

How much difference does insulation make?

A large one on a habitable room. It changes the build up height, the trim detail and often the door thresholds, so it needs deciding before the quote, not after.

Related services